I'm glad I'm not the only one pissed off with the fate of Tonks. I can't imagine why her character did such a flip. babies babies motherhood babies. So much depth in the way Rowling depicts the roles of women.

But be that as it may, I loved it - as much as I love any Harry Potter book, which is in pieces. The Hogwarts battle was awesome. And I'm glad Snape wasn't just 'evil'. That would have been unimaginative.

The whole dead jedi talk with Dumbledore was a bit irritating, but the epiologue was worse. Maybe skipping far in the future is her ingenious way of making us never want to know any more about the series?

Poor Dobby and Hedwig.